Shin Okinawa: I highly doubt people eating this food have a better shot of living till 100+

It was with much trepidation that we went to this restaurant.  Lots of mixed reviews.  But as this restaurant is very close to where I live, it could easily be a place where we could hang out frequently.  Plus, while I do not claim to know a lot about Okinawan cuisine (a very specific type of Japanese), I am of course familiar with the stories of Okinawan longevity, which they generally attribute to their special diet.   So – upside potential was close, healthy, and relatively inexpensive.  Worth the risk.

It was a bad omen when I called them and asked how much corkage is.  They said $26.  Um, I am asking about wine, not Sake.  Nope, $26 for wine.   Well, we planned on ordering Sake anyway.  

So I perused the menu looking for unique items, especially those known to be Okinawan.  We focused on a lot of off-menu specials, and the ones marked “recommended” on the menu.  We decided on 7 items to start.

Sting Ray Fins:  If you made squid into squid jerky, that would probably be a comparable dish.  Tasted kind of fishy and was almost impossible to chew.  $6.75

Spicy Black Sausage – This is very greasy Portughese sausage with shredded iceberg lettuce as an accompaniment.  Husband said it needed mustard to cut the fat.   $6.75

Stir Fried Cabbage, Simmered Pork, Bitter Melon:  This is the dish most extolled by others.  It is important to note that I love bitter melon.  I order it frequently at Chinese restaurants, and even buy it and make it at home.    But you do have to treat it a little bit to make it less bitter.  It’s best to stew/boil it in some way.  THis was pretty much just chopped up and stir fried – no sign of even a parboil.  Husband picked out the pork, we could not eat this dish.  $7.50

Aloe and Seaweed with Plum Sauce:
  I have never eaten aloe before.  Applied it as lotion, grew it in the yard, but never consumed it.  This was a very exciting dish for me as I have heard that Aloe has many health benefits.  This dish really grew on me.  THe also was cooked into a gel with the consistency of jelly fish.  IT paired will with the shiso/ponzu/seaweed accompaniments.   I enjoyed this dish.  $5.75

Soruru Japanese Marando (Deep Fried little fish) :  I think the fish were frozen/defrosted.  There was a mayo dip.  Not exciting.  $6.75

Takoyaki – Balls made of dough and octopus pieces and then breaded/deep fried.  Covered with bonito shavings and served with mayo for dipping.    I have had this dish before, but the texture was always nasty and greasy.  These had a really interesting gummy texture similar to a rice noodle.  This was our favorite dish.  $5.00

Chef’s Special Okinawan fried rice:  Traditional Okinawan black rice mixed with the chef’s choice of the best meats and vegetables in the house.  Ours came out with Spam, egg, scallion, and celery.  Sigh.  $8

At this point, we cut our losses and left without ordering anything else.  Including our $30 bottle of Sake, it still came to $100. (Wound up going out for some  wine then filled up on a Dove Bar.

I really tried hard to find dishes that exemplified the healthy eating of those who live in Okinawa.  I know they have a diet rich in fish, fruit, steamed rice. 

This is just not that kind of food.  It tastes like Japanese fast food to me. The ingredients are mostly processed, frozen/defrosted, sourced from other places, etc. Everything has a large amount of fat added to cover up the low quality ingredients.  I actually asked them about Exile Kiss’ claim that they buy their noodles as opposed to making their own.  The waitress confirmed it, which is why we did not order that dish. 

Their cocktail and beverage menu is substantial.  In conjuction with the inordinately high corkage for a casual place like this, plus the greasy/salty food, it is clear what they are going for. This place is a bar first, restaurant second.  This is meant to be a money making machine; keep the food margins low and the alcohol margins high. 

A shame. 

Shin Okinawa Izakaya
1880 W. Carson Street, Suite #A
Torrance, CA 90501
Tel: (310) 618-8357

Hours: [Lunch] Mon – Fri, 11:30 a.m. – 2:00 p.m.
[Dinner] 7 Days A Week, 5:30 p.m. – 12:00 Midnight

7 thoughts on “Shin Okinawa: I highly doubt people eating this food have a better shot of living till 100+

  1. Hi The Foodie Traveler, Thanks for the detailed review. My sincerest condolences on your visit; I feel partially responsible in some way. 😦 Like you, I found quite a few of their dishes underwhelming or just not good (avoid). But there are quite a few worth trying, such as their Rafutei (classic Okinawan dish / Pork Belly), Soki Buni (Stewed version and Grilled version), and a few others like their Beni Imo. These I found wonderfully delicious (as did the Izakaya Hounds I brought with me). Unfortunately, it seems you hit all the land mines. Looking back on my multiple visits (and yours) I can see that without careful ordering one could order all the dishes that the kitchen doesn’t do well enough and come away disappointed (and for a consistently good restaurant, there shouldn’t be so many misses). Thanks again for your thoughts.

  2. LOL.  I did try hard to get the best and most authentic items, but my Okinawan knowledge is very limited and I figured I might be ordering wrong.  Also, I was really trying to focus on the healthier options and that is probably not the right move for this kind of place, as their specialty seems to be more izakaya like, and by that I mean stuff that pairs well with alcohol.  I didn’t like it, but I have no regrets about going.  You were very fair in your review meaning I knew exactly what I was getting into before I went.  I only gave it 50-50, but was hopeful.  I am still open to trying again some time. 

  3. Hi The Foodie Traveler, There were definitely some problem dishes; again my condolences. 😦 To let you know, I just came back from a follow-up visit (bringing some friends visiting from out-of-town that wanted to try the Okinawan eatery). For my 5th visit, their So-ki Buni (Long-Stewed Pork Ribs) was wonderful! (just as good as before) Their Rafutei (Pork Belly) was really good (again) tonight, as was their BBQ So-ki (Roasted Ribs). Not trying to make excuses for the restaurant, just wanted to report back that the things they do well was still good, but we ran across a few duds as well (their new Unagi Kimo Yaki (Roasted Eel Liver(!)) was a bit too fishy; their Sata Andagi (Okinawan Donut) was still so-so.

  4. Thanks for the followup, exilekiss.  Funny, the eel liver and donuts were high on the list of the 2nd tier items I would have gotten that night.  Also, I skipped all the stewed food and I wanted to choose one of those items as well. 

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s